Suspected serial killer Rex Heuermann is accused of killing seven ladies and dumping their our bodies in numerous areas throughout Lengthy Island, New York, over a horrifying 18-year stretch. He pleaded not responsible to the murders of the seven ladies whose stays had been discovered scattered on Lengthy Island between 1993 and 2011. Creator Vanessa Cuti, who previously manned the close by Suffolk Police tip line, solely tells In Contact concerning the cellphone calls she fielded after the primary 4 ladies’s our bodies had been found in 2010.
“It simply exploded. There have been a whole bunch and a whole bunch of calls,” Cuti explains to investigative reporter Kristin Thorne as a part of a brand new true crime video sequence, In Contact Investigates, revealing lots of the callers questioned if the killer was their very own boyfriend or husband.
Cuti was employed by the Suffolk Police Division for a public relations place in 2010, the place she labored in a tiny room and operated what she stated was an “outdated timey crimson plastic cellphone with a curly wire and push buttons.” On the time, she labored alone as she answered a “manageable caseload” of cellphone calls till ladies’s our bodies had been found after being dumped in a close-by space known as Gilgo Seaside on Lengthy Island.
From the preliminary investigation, police suspected that they had a serial killer on their palms and the homicide case gripped the whole world. Residents of the suburban cities had been fearful after the our bodies had been present in 2010 and 2011 and because the homicides grew to become extra broadly identified, a number of documentaries and movies had been launched concerning the killings.
Cuti says the tip line cellphone calls she was fielding on the time consisted of “something you may consider.”
“There have been quite a lot of psychics calling. What amazed me most was that so many individuals had been calling about males of their lives. Males that they had identified,” the previous authorities worker explains, confirming there have been ladies calling in believing their husband or boyfriend must be investigated.
“It was principally individuals from their previous. I don’t keep in mind anybody saying my present husband, nevertheless it was, individuals would say, I had this loopy ex-boyfriend after I was so-and-so,” she describes. “You guys actually need to look into him. And it was not only one name like that.”
13 years later, in July 2023, authorities arrested the New York Metropolis architect, 61, exterior his workplace in midtown Manhattan.
Heuermann was charged with the murders of seven ladies, together with Megan Waterman, 22, Melissa Barthelemy, 24, Amber Lynn Costello, 27, and Maureen Brainard-Barnes, 25 — 4 of the 11 victims whose stays had been found close to Lengthy Island’s Gilgo Seaside.
In keeping with the Suffolk County Police Commissioner, Heuermann’s ex-wife, Asa Ellerup, and two youngsters had been out of city when he allegedly dedicated the murders. Ellerup filed for divorce from Heuermann in 2023 days after he was arrested.
Though he’s now headed to trial, the married father of two continues to insist he’s harmless and denies killing anybody.
When Heuermann was lastly jailed in Suffolk County whereas awaiting trial for the crimes, Cuti admits she was shocked by his arrest. “I used to be shocked, actually, to evade seize for that lengthy after which to be captured,” she says. “And I used to be shocked. I couldn’t imagine that they discovered that they discovered him.”
