A seemingly exciting threesome took a dramatic turn when arguments broke out and wine glasses shattered in the kitchen, leaving one participant stunned and reflective.
The Initial Spark on a Dating App
I matched with Dennis on Hinge while looking for casual encounters. His charming smile drew me in, and our playful conversation quickly led to plans for drinks at a local pub that evening. An Irish band played as we laughed over pints, building instant chemistry.
Enamored, I accepted his invitation back to his place. That’s when he casually revealed, “I’m in an open relationship, and my girlfriend would love to meet you.” Surprised, I asked if she knew about our date. “Oh yes, she chose you,” he replied with a laugh.
As a bisexual woman new to such dynamics, the situation felt unclear. He hadn’t mentioned it upfront, but the mood was good, so I went along. At his apartment, Cleo wasn’t home yet. “She’s out with friends and will join later,” he explained as we started making out on the sofa.
Disappointing Encounters and Rising Doubts
The sex with Dennis proved average—vanilla and brief. Soon after, Cleo arrived. Beautiful with long red hair and curvy hips, she smiled warmly and asked seductively, “Do you want to go down on me?” Hypnotized, I agreed. Dennis discreetly left the room, and Cleo and I shared an intense, enjoyable experience alone. Afterward, I left, chalking up the oddity to my inexperience.
Dennis set up a WhatsApp group for the three of us, but only he initiated meets. Subsequent visits promised threesomes but ended in solo sex with him. Cleo was absent each time, with vague excuses offered. His charm faded, and the encounters grew boring, eroding my interest.
The Explosive Threesome Breakdown
Next time, both waited naked, ready for action. I asked Cleo about her absences; she vaguely said, “At my parents, I needed some time.” Five minutes into the threesome, she screamed in frustration and stormed to the kitchen.
Still naked on the sofa, I overheard her yell, “Why did you choose her, though?” Dennis shouted back, “You said you wanted someone like her.” Glass smashed behind the door. He peeked out: “Sorry, we’ll just be a moment.”
The fight escalated. “Those noises you were making were obscene,” she accused. “I make the same noises with you!” he protested. “No you do not. I know you don’t want me, and that’s why she’s here,” she fired back.
It hit me: this was his scheme all along. Cleo seemed dragged into it, unhappy in their open relationship or the threesomes. Feeling like a soap opera extra amid flying wine glasses, I dressed quietly and slipped out.
Escape and Key Takeaways
I blocked the WhatsApp group and Dennis on Hinge immediately. Cleo’s allure had kept me returning, but clearly, she didn’t want this. Threesomes can work if all parties consent enthusiastically—but vague setups from dating apps spell trouble.
Now, if a guy mentions a partner post-drinks, it’s an instant no. Always seek full details upfront to avoid being pulled into someone else’s drama.
