Former Abercrombie & Fitch CEO Michael Jeffries, 81, pressed prison doctors to declare him incompetent for trial during a federal competency hearing. He faces one count of sex trafficking and 15 counts of interstate prostitution for allegedly abusing over a dozen young male models from 2008 to 2015.
Allegations of Luring Models to Sex Parties
Prosecutors state that Jeffries, along with partner Matthew Smith and associate James Jacobson, enticed men to drug-fueled sex parties in the Hamptons with promises of modeling gigs for the retailer. Victims believed participation offered career advancement, especially given their financial vulnerabilities—the youngest was 19.
Itineraries mimicked photo shoot schedules, omitting details of required sexual acts like anal intercourse, large sex toys, high-pressure enemas, poppers, Viagra, and penile injections of erection-inducing substances. Staff controlled access, collected phones and wallets, and enforced nondisclosure agreements. Victims traveled to New York City, England, France, Italy, Morocco, and Saint Barthelemy for encounters. Threats of exposure prompted surveillance and intimidation via a security firm.
Defense Claims Mental Incompetence
Defense attorneys assert Jeffries cannot stand trial due to Alzheimer’s disease and Lewy body dementia. Clinical neuropsychologist Dr. Jacqueline C. Valdes, who evaluated him since October 2023, noted his initial confusion, shuffling gait, and tremors.
Valdes testified about a recorded prison phone call where Jeffries demanded doctors "better find me incompetent." She described this as disinhibited behavior, citing instances of rude language like "b***h" toward mental health staff and overly personal interactions. Smith’s account included Jeffries found incapacitated in a neighbor’s yard in underwear.
Evidence points to cognitive decline starting in 2013 with mild brain atrophy on MRI, worsening after a 2018 fall in South Africa. Pre-indictment symptoms involved hallucinations, wandering, delusions, and dream enactment.
Courtroom Observations
Jeffries arrived alert in a slim-fit suit, ankle monitor visible. He shook hands, chatted with team members, greeted a reporter, and walked steadily to the restroom with son Andrew, responding "Fine" to health queries—no cane or mobility aid needed. He showed impatience at times, nearly interrupting.
Prosecutors highlight improved cognitive test scores this year, which Valdes linked to medication, plus analyses from their experts and over 100 recorded calls with Smith from prison.
Recruitment Tactics Detailed in Indictment
Jacobson traveled domestically and internationally to scout models, conducting paid "tryouts." He compensated referrers at Smith’s direction. Aspiring models faced undisclosed sexual demands at controlled events incorporating Abercrombie products.
Next Steps in Proceedings
The hearing continues Wednesday with defense witnesses and prosecution audio. Jury selection begins October 26 if Judge Nusrat Choudhury deems Jeffries competent.
