The Hochul administration is being accused of overlaying up crimes in prisons by downgrading assaults dedicated by inmates towards guards as “harassment” or “disruptive conduct” as a substitute of assaults.
A bombshell Dec. 31, 2025 memo issued by the state Corrections Division’s deputy commissioner Michael D’Amore lays out examples of what constitutes an assault and what’s thought-about the decrease classification of harassment or disruptive conduct.
“The Division has redefined the Uncommon Incident (UI) class, and created harassment as a reportable UI,” D’Amore mentioned within the memo despatched to all jail superintendents and watch commanders.
For instance, an inmate who rips off the shirt pocket of a guard delivering meals needs to be charged with disruptive conduct or harassment — not assault, D’Amore mentioned.
The inmate would solely be charged with assault if he smashes the guard’s face into the safety fence whereas ripping his shirt, D’Amore mentioned, citing a hypothetical case.
Republican gubernatorial candidate Bruce Blakeman slammed the memo as gentle on felons and accused his election opponent Gov. Kathy Hochul’s crew of overlaying up crimes inmates commit towards officers.
“Let’s be clear: when an inmate grabs an officer, throws objects at an officer, or drags an officer right into a cell, that’s assault,” Blakeman mentioned.
“You don’t make prisons safer by taking part in phrase video games. You make them safer by backing correction officers and holding violent offenders accountable. When Albany downplays violence towards officers, it emboldens dangerous conduct and tells the women and men defending our prisons that their security comes second to political optics. That’s unacceptable.”
Corrections officers view the change as retribution from the Hochul admin after a devastating unlawful strike final 12 months led her to fireplace 2,000 officers, leaving the already precarious system much more dangerously understaffed.
“They’re going to make use of that towards all of us. They’re doing every thing they’ll to harass the workers and punish us and make life simpler for the inmates,” one corrections officer advised The Submit.
The memo cited different reclassifications or downgrades. As an example, throwing an empty milk carton in the back of a guard can be written up as disruptive conduct or harassment — and solely represent an assault if the inmate hurled a frozen milk carton on the guard.
In one other hypothetical case cited by D’Amore, an inmate abruptly runs to the again of the cell whereas an officer is attempting to take away the mechanical restraints from him — pulling the officer’s arms into the cell. The motion can be labeled as harassment or disruptive conduct, not an assault.
The inmate can be charged with assault if he swings the restraints and hits an officer within the shoulder and thigh, D’Amore mentioned.
The union representing correctional officers in prisons slammed the reclassification.
“Mark our phrases: A 12 months from now, DOCCS [Department of Corrections and Community Supervision] will probably be touting that the variety of assaults has dropped and prisons are a lot safer when, in actuality, it’s as a result of they refuse to acknowledge the cruel actuality that our members are going through harmful conditions daily.,” the Correctional Officers and Police Benevolent Affiliation mentioned in a press release Tuesday.
“These harmful conditions received’t be totally tracked beneath DOCCS’ new definition,” the union mentioned. “Decreasing assault numbers with out additional defining different harmful conditions runs the chance of constructing it seem like the failed insurance policies of the NYS Legislature are working.”
The union advocated strongly for extra definitions for inmate offenses to incorporate menacing and reckless endangerment.
“NYSCOPBA refused to consent to the assault definition modifications with out these essential expansions, as narrowing the assault definition alone fails to seize the complete realities of the dangers our officers encounter each day. Regardless of our place, DOCCS has proceeded unilaterally to implement the revised definitions,” the union mentioned.
Over 2,000 nationwide guard troops stay deployed within the prisons as DOCCS hasn’t come anyplace close to to rebuilding its workforce pre-strike.
The strike was precipitated in-part by a unique memo despatched round by DOCCS about decreasing staffing ranges for services.
Blakeman additionally mentioned the New York HALT Act limiting solitary confinement has led to extra inmate assaults on corrections officers.
Since Hochul signed the HALT Act in 2022, violence inside New York’s correctional services has skyrocketed, he mentioned.
Inmate-on-staff assaults surged to 2,072 in 2024, a 39% enhance from the 1,490 recorded in 2022, the 12 months HALT was enacted.
Inmate-on-inmate assaults reached a whopping 2,984 in 2024, greater than double the 1,474 tallied two years prior.
“These numbers expose the reality Hochul needs to cover,” Blakeman mentioned. “Her insurance policies made prisons extra harmful, and now her administration is reclassifying assaults to make the statistics look higher. This isn’t reform — it’s a cover-up.”
D’Amore, within the memo, defended the reclassification as truthful, and never going gentle on inmate violence.
“Elementary to the willpower that an assault has occurred is the intent to injure one other individual, whether or not or not an harm has occurred,” the deputy commissioner for correctional services mentioned.
An inmate will probably be charged with assault if he throws bodily fluid or excrement at a corrections officer, as would fondling the buttocks of a staffer, added D’Amore.
DOCCS mentioned that “Any declare that the definition of ‘assault’ has been watered down is patently false.”
“The security of everybody in our services is our high precedence, which is why, pursuant to the memorandum of settlement (MOA) with NYSCOPBA that ended the unlawful job motion, we agreed to fulfill and assessment the present definition of assault used to trace violence,” the division mentioned in a press release.
“The brand new definition was developed with NYSCOPBA management, who’ve been totally concerned and included in these discussions on behalf of their members. These modifications enable us to carry incarcerated people who assault and harass our employees accountable to the fullest extent of the regulation and permit us to higher determine cases of bodily hurt so we are able to intervene sooner and higher defend our employees.”
Hochul spokesperson Matthew Janiszewski mentioned the transfer strengthens “security and safety inside our correction services” and mentioned union officers had been concerned within the talks on the coverage.
“Governor Hochul respects the extraordinary work of New York’s corrections officers, and we are going to proceed to associate with Commissioner Martuscello and employees to make sure our services are run in a protected and environment friendly method for all,” Hochul’s spokesperson mentioned.
The top of the union representing officers patrolling Nassau County jails was horrified by the state’s reclassification, saying that it received’t assist handle a staffing scarcity in correctional services – which led to backups in native jails as state prisons had been unable to just accept new inmates for months after the strike.
“The memo is telling supervisors to govern the classification of assaults,” mentioned Peter Lilli, president of the Nassau County Correction Officers Benevolent Affiliation. “Violence is resulting in a statewide recruitment concern.”
Saritha Komatireddy, a Republican candidate for state legal professional basic and former federal prosecutor mentioned, “Minimizing assaults on regulation enforcement is unacceptable and unjust. Everybody in New York deserves to be protected, together with correctional officers who put themselves in danger daily.
“As a federal prosecutor, I went after those that attacked jail guards, to the fullest the fullest extent of the regulation. As Lawyer Common, I’ll have the again of ALL our regulation enforcement, together with COs.”
