B.C. Supreme Court Greenlights Settlement
The B.C. Supreme Court approves a $475,000 settlement in a class-action lawsuit against the Vancouver Whitecaps and Major League Soccer. The case stems from promotional materials for a 2024 match against Inter Miami, where star players like Lionel Messi did not appear despite heavy promotion.
Justice Andrew Majawa deems the agreement fair and reasonable in this novel dispute. He notes the plaintiff’s claims of breach of contract, unjust enrichment, and violations of provincial consumer laws and federal competition rules. The team maintains it had no influence over Inter Miami’s player selections.
Lawsuit Details and Fan Disappointment
Fans purchased tickets costing hundreds of dollars, drawn by promotions featuring Messi and Sergio Busquets. The class encompasses roughly 50,000 ticket buyers for the May 2024 game. Many expressed frustration, with young supporters displaying signs of disappointment at the venue.
The team offers no admission of liability but commits to highlighting ticketing terms on its website. These terms clarify no guarantees exist for specific players’ participation.
Settlement Distribution and Changes
After deducting lawyer fees of about $156,000—roughly one-third of the total—and a $1,500 honorarium for lead plaintiff Ho Chun, the funds support three B.C. sports charities. Beneficiaries include KidSport B.C., which aids families facing financial barriers to youth sports; Canada Scores, offering free after-school programs; and the Boys and Girls Club of B.C.’s South Coast.
Justice Majawa describes the donation as a meaningful contribution and praises the ticketing practice updates.
Judge Addresses Objections and Risks
A limited number of class members opt out, with few objections. Majawa dismisses some as based on unsubstantiated online rumors, including one flagged for apparent AI-generated content with ‘AI hallucinations.’
“I accept that this is a novel and complex claim that there are a number of possible defences available,” Majawa states. “The settlement is not required to be perfect.”
He acknowledges online vitriol faced by Ho Chun, including false claims damaging his reputation. “This misinformation or disinformation will remain on the internet and be associated with him forever,” Majawa notes. “Being subject to such negative online criticism may discourage people from putting themselves forward as representative plaintiff.”
Fans receive partial compensation through free tickets to future games and food discounts.
