For greater than a month, federal immigration officers surveilled Bayron Rovidio Marin in a hospital mattress at Harbor-UCLA Medical Middle, the place he lay recuperating from severe accidents to his leg after an encounter with brokers at a Carson automobile wash they raided. He was by no means charged, and his attorneys say he was shackled to his mattress for a number of days and couldn’t converse privately with medical doctors or authorized counsel.
Over the weekend, a federal choose issued a brief restraining order requiring immigration officers to take away the guards watching over Bayron Rovidio Marin, take off {the handcuffs} and go away him unrestrained.
“He’s presently detained beneath restrictions that restrict his entry to counsel, medical suppliers, and household,” U.S. District Choose Cynthia Valenzuela wrote in her Oct. 4 order. “He has been questioned by authorities officers whereas in ache and beneath the affect of remedy. He can’t place telephone calls and stays handcuffed to a hospital mattress regardless of a damaged leg that stops him from strolling. He has acquired not more than a imprecise rationalization for his detention, and Respondents’ proffered excuses for delaying a proper discover are unsupported by details.”
For the document:
4:09 p.m. Oct. 7, 2025A earlier model of this text stated Bayron Rovidio Marin was handcuffed to a hospital mattress for greater than a month. He was handcuffed for a number of days, in line with considered one of his attorneys.
Regardless of Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s insistence on holding the person, Valenzuela stated the federal government failed to supply any proof that he had “violated any regulation or regulation” or present that he was a “flight threat.”
Thus far, ICE has not positioned Rovidio Marin in removing proceedings, charged him with violating immigration regulation, set bond, issued a Discover to Seem or in any other case processed him, in line with the order. The federal government informed the court docket that they’d decide the immigration standing of Rovidio Marin as soon as he was launched from the hospital. His attorneys argued being indefinitely held with none prices is a transparent constitutional violation.
The Division of Homeland Safety and the medical heart didn’t instantly reply to a request for remark.
Below federal regulation, officers initiating warrantless arrests should present the particular person in custody a purpose why they have been arrested or detained and inside 48 hours decide if the particular person will stay in custody, launched on bond or given a discover to seem in court docket and an arrest warrant issued. These guidelines are solely waived in extraordinary circumstances. The choose famous that the September 11 assaults beforehand certified as an “extraordinary circumstance” in delaying notices to seem to noncitizen detainees, however stated that Rovidio Marin has been held “considerably longer.”
Kyle Cheney, with Politico, first posted concerning the case on social media.
It’s unclear precisely how he was injured, however his attorneys say that Rovidio Marin had been on the automobile wash on Aug. 27 when immigration brokers doing a “roving patrol” stormed in and raided it.
In an emailed press assertion, Cynthia Santiago, lawyer for CLEAN Carwash Employee Middle, and Nicolas Thompson-Lleras, lawyer for CHIRLA, stated he suffered extreme accidents and was arrested by Border Patrol brokers who transferred him into ICE custody.
“For 37 days, our shopper was compelled to endure medical remedy and restoration with ICE brokers in his room, 24 hours a day, seven days every week,” the assertion learn. “ICE brokers listened to each dialog between him and his medical doctors,” they acknowledged. “They interrogated him whereas he was in ache and beneath the affect of remedy. They didn’t allow him to see his household and eliminated his entry to telephone calls.”
In response to the choose’s order, Rovidio Marin has been beneath the supervision of ICE, which contracted with Spectrum Detention Providers to supply guards on the hospital the place he was taken.
As soon as admitted, he was positioned beneath what is called a “blackout” process for sufferers in law-enforcement custody, making it tougher for anybody to seek out him. He was registered beneath the pseudonym “Har Maine UNK 13.”
Two to 4 uniformed guards — both Spectrum workers or ICE brokers — “have been constantly stationed in Petitioner’s hospital room, monitoring him always, together with whereas he sleeps, eats, makes use of the restroom, or receives medical care,” in line with a declaration referenced within the order.
“It’s basic you can’t be detained indefinitely with out prices,” stated Jean Reisz, co-director of the USC Gould Faculty of Legislation Immigration Clinic, who’s representing Rovidio Marin within the habeas case. “Freedom from restraint is the cornerstone of our society, and so to arrest somebody and withhold their liberty for an prolonged time frame with none prices, it’s antithetical to our constitutional system and our immigration legal guidelines. Our immigration legal guidelines do present for the rights of immigrants as properly.”
The momentary restraining order expires Oct. 18.
